top of page



The New Europol Regulation (COM(2026) 580): Europol as Investigative Infrastructure and What It Means for Defence Rights
Oliver Wallasch’s commentary on the Commission’s proposal for a new Europol Regulation, COM(2026) 580 final, concludes that the proposal makes Europol’s work product usable against the accused without making it verifiable by the accused. The post summarises the key findings and the provisions at issue and offers the commentary and the Commission documents as PDF downloads.

Joint Defense Team
7 days ago8 min read


SkyECC Evidence Excluded in Italy: Catanzaro Court Finds No Effective Remedy in France
The Tribunale di Catanzaro (judgment no. 320/2026) excluded all SkyECC chats obtained from France by EIO because the defendants had no remedy against their gathering and transfer in either Italy or France. What the reasons say and what defence lawyers elsewhere can take from them.

Joint Defense Team
Nov 97 min read


Europol Digital Forensics Gap Analysis (2026): What It Reveals About Digital Evidence and Why Defence Rights Must Keep Pace
Europol's report Digital forensics: gap analysis (16 October 2026) finds that the forensic tools, resources and expertise of EU law enforcement are falling behind digital evidence. It admits fragmented tool validation and manual chain-of-custody records, yet never mentions the defence. What this means for EncroChat, SkyECC and ANOM cases and for Article 6 ECHR.

Joint Defense Team
Nov 28 min read


Has GrapheneOS Been Cracked? What Recent Police Cases Reveal About Pixel and GrapheneOS Security
Has GrapheneOS been cracked? Every confirmed police case so far involves a seized phone, not remote access. What the German BKA case, the Dutch Pixel raids and leaked Cellebrite documents show about Pixel and GrapheneOS security.

Joint Defense Team
Oct 3110 min read


ANOM before the Dutch Supreme Court (Hoge Raad): A Misled Lithuanian Judge and the Limits of Mutual Trust
The Dutch Supreme Court (Hoge Raad) has an ANOM case before it in which the foreign court order behind the evidence was obtained by misleading a judge in Vilnius. What the Lithuanian documents mean for the interstate principle of trust, Article 6 ECHR and ANOM defendants across Europe.

Joint Defense Team
Oct 237 min read


Octopus Conference 2026: The Budapest Convention at 25 and the Defence Perspective on Cross-Border Digital Evidence
At the Council of Europe's Octopus Conference 2026 in Strasbourg, the Joint Defense Team argued that faster cross-border access to digital evidence under the Second Additional Protocol and the EU e-evidence Regulation must remain subject to the safeguards of Article 15 of the Budapest Convention and to effective defence rights.

Joint Defense Team
Oct 185 min read


SkyECC before the CJEU (C-625/25 Prudniez): Member States Split on an Effective Remedy Against European Investigation Order Evidence, Advocate General's Opinion on 19 November 2026
In Case C-625/25 (Prudniez), the CJEU must decide whether Article 14 of Directive 2014/41/EU and Article 47 of the Charter require France to give people prosecuted in other Member States a remedy against SkyECC evidence it transmitted by European Investigation Order; the Advocate General's Opinion is due on 19 November 2026.

Joint Defense Team
Sep 216 min read


Digital Evidence Cannot Stand Above National Law: EncroChat, SkyECC and ANOM Before European Courts
Seven Joint Defense Team lawyers on EncroChat, SkyECC and ANOM: why mutual trust cannot replace judicial review of cross-border digital evidence in Europe.

Joint Defense Team
Aug 316 min read


Project Trojan Shield: How the ANOM Operation Deceived the Courts That Authorised It
Verified documents from the FBI's Project Trojan Shield show that the courts asked to authorise the ANOM data collection were deliberately deceived about the platform's true origin and operator, a finding that affects ANOM prosecutions across numerous countries.

Joint Defense Team
Jul 84 min read


SkyECC Before the ECtHR: Norway Cases Expand the European Challenge to Encrypted Evidence
The ECtHR has communicated new SkyECC cases from Norway, raising fundamental questions on fair trial rights under Article 6 ECHR. Together with Silgir v Germany (EncroChat) and ongoing ANOM proceedings, the Court is shaping a European framework for the use of encrypted communication evidence in cross-border criminal cases.

Joint Defense Team
May 255 min read


Laundering the Source: A Former UDEF Chief Describes How Spanish Police Conceal the True Origin of Encrypted-Communication Evidence from ANOM & SkyECC
A former UDEF chief alleges that Spanish police systematically concealed the true origin of encrypted communications evidence from ANOM and SkyECC by using “parallel construction”. The article explores the implications for fair trial rights, judicial scrutiny and the admissibility of digital evidence across Europe.

Maria Barbancho
May 184 min read


Europol, Shadow Data and the Rule of Law: Why Secret Surveillance Must Face Judicial Control
Recent revelations about Europol’s alleged shadow data repository raise serious concerns about the lawful collection and use of evidence in cross-border investigations. Against the backdrop of Sky ECC, EncroChat and ANOM cases, the article highlights the urgent need for transparency and independent judicial scrutiny to safeguard fair trial rights and the integrity of criminal proceedings.

Joint Defense Team
May 72 min read


SkyECC and EncroChat: Italian Court Developments Strengthening Defence Challenges to Digital Evidence
In recent days, numerous press reports have appeared concerning decisions by Italian judges declaring EncroChat and SkyECC evidence inadmissible.

Daniele Fiorino
Feb 42 min read


EncroChat and SkyECC: Why European Courts are Questioning the Reliability of Digital Evidence
In recent weeks, the legal landscape regarding the reliability of digital evidence has faced intense scrutiny. As landmark rulings emerge across Europe, the "blind trust" in encrypted data is being replaced by fundamental principles of a fair trial.

Joint Defense Team
Jan 313 min read


ANOM Leaks: When Justice Becomes a Victim of Deception
Christian Lödden reveals the ANOM leaks: How FBI and Lithuanian police misled judges – hundreds of convictions in Germany and Europe now at risk.

Joint Defense Team
Sep 28, 20253 min read


Cour de cassation: the absence of a right of appeal in France does not pose a constitutional problem - Implications for SkyECC and EncroChat cases
On 3 June 2025, the Cour de cassation refused to refer to the Conseil constitutionnel a question on the constitutionality of French law which, as currently drafted, denies the possibility of an effective remedy to persons prosecuted in criminal proceedings abroad, but on the basis of SkyECC evidence gathered in French proceedings.

Guillaume Martine
Jun 11, 20255 min read
bottom of page