ECtHR criminal case law: October 2026 | ECtHR Criminal Law Monthly


Reviewed by Bojana Franović Kovačević, Member, Montenegro
ECtHR criminal case law in October 2026 centred on access to communications and devices. Of the five judgments in this edition, three found violations of Article 8: in Anar Mammadov v. Azerbaijan investigators searched phones without any authorisation, in Cengiz v. Türkiye prison visits were recorded without individual assessment, and in Dogar v. Romania a prosecutor alone authorised interception.
Each Article 8 finding turns on a missing safeguard (prior authorisation, individual assessment or independent review), and these are the points for defence lawyers to test first when intercepted or extracted data appears in a case file. The other two judgments concern judge-made offences and detention after a European Arrest Warrant surrender. Our overview of proceedings before the European Court of Human Rights explains how complaints reach Strasbourg.
Anar Mammadov v. Azerbaijan
Application nos. 12043/19 and 50484/20, Chamber judgment (Third Section) of 6 October 2026, not yet final. Outcome: violation of Articles 8 and 10 ECHR and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1; no violation of Article 18.
The facts
Anar Mammadov, a journalist and editor of the news site criminal.az, was convicted of offences including disseminating open calls against the State after writing about the 2018 unrest in Ganja. During the investigation his phones, laptop and documents were seized from his flat and the contents of his phones were inspected. The phones were never treated as evidence, but the Government could not show that they had been returned.
The Court's reasoning
In Anar Mammadov v. Azerbaijan the European Court of Human Rights held that the seizure and the phone inspection interfered with rights under Article 8 ECHR (§ 61), and that the investigator had relied on two inconsistent grounds for the seizure without justifying either (§§ 66–73).
No decision authorised the inspection of the phones' contents, and a search left to an investigator's "unfettered discretion" cannot comply with Article 8 (§ 75). With no later judicial review either (§§ 77–79), the interference was not "in accordance with the law" (§§ 80–81). Keeping phones that were not evidence also breached Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 (§§ 93–97).
Why it matters for the defence
Reading a phone's contents is a separate interference that needs its own authorisation; the warrant or consent for taking the device does not cover it. When the admissibility of extracted data is argued, defence lawyers can demand the specific decision that authorised the extraction and any judicial review of it. The judgment also supports applications for the return of devices that are not evidence.
Cengiz v. Türkiye
Application no. 25406/22, Chamber judgment (Second Section) of 13 October 2026, not yet final; available in French only. Article: 8 ECHR. Outcome: violation (unanimous); EUR 1,500 for non-pecuniary damage.
The facts
Abdi Cengiz, a former judge of the Turkish Court of Cassation, was serving a sentence for membership of an armed terrorist organisation. Under Article 83 § 4 of Law no. 5275, introduced in 2021, his visiting-room conversations with family were audio-recorded for one year.
The Court's reasoning
In Cengiz v. Türkiye the European Court of Human Rights accepted that the provision itself was "in accordance with the law", since it regulated notice, purposes, use and deletion of recordings (§§ 54–59).
The breach lay in its application: recording followed automatically for every prisoner in the category and lasted a year without any individual assessment (§§ 65–66). The courts checked only the legal basis (§ 67), so no relevant and sufficient reasons showed the measure was necessary (§ 68).
Why it matters for the defence
Cengiz supports challenges to surveillance attached to a category of offence rather than to the person. Where a client is monitored because of the charge alone, the defence can demand the individual decision and its reasons, and contest any review that only confirms the statutory basis.
Dogar v. Romania
Application no. 23011/16, Committee judgment (Fourth Section) of 27 October 2026, final; available in French only. Articles: 6 and 8 ECHR. Outcome: violation of Article 8 (unanimous); the Article 6 complaint was rejected as inadmissible.
The facts
In 2003 a Romanian prosecutor authorised and extended the interception of Nicolae Dogar's communications under the former Code of Criminal Procedure, in an investigation into economic offences. In 2015 the High Court of Cassation and Justice sentenced him to five years' imprisonment for tax evasion and money laundering.
The Court's reasoning
In Dogar v. Romania the European Court of Human Rights applied Calmanovici v. Romania: the 2003 law let no judge or other independent authority review whether interception was justified, which was enough for a violation of Article 8.
The Article 6 complaint failed: the applicant had the recordings and transcripts, challenged them only in general terms, and was convicted mainly on documents. Evidence obtained in breach of Article 8 does not in itself make a trial unfair (Bykov v. Russia [GC], § 104) (§§ 26–31).
Why it matters for the defence
For intercepts received through mutual legal assistance, the defence should ask who authorised the measure abroad and whether a court reviewed it. To turn an Article 8 breach into an Article 6 argument, the defence must show that the intercepts carried real weight in the conviction and must raise specific objections to the recordings at trial.
Lo Sicco v. Italy
Application no. 14417/09, Chamber judgment (First Section) of 29 October 2026, not yet final; available in French only. Articles: 7 ECHR and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1. Outcome: violation of Article 7 (five votes to two); the confiscation complaint was not examined separately.
The facts
Pietro Lo Sicco, a Palermo building entrepreneur, was convicted of concorso esterno in associazione mafiosa (external complicity in a mafia-type association, an offence built by the courts from Articles 110 and 416 bis of the Criminal Code) for conduct from 1980 onwards. His sentence of seven years' imprisonment became final in 2008 and his property was confiscated.
The Court's reasoning
In Lo Sicco v. Italy the European Court of Human Rights noted that Court of Cassation case law conflicted from 1987 until the joint chambers' Demitry judgment of October 1994 (§§ 76–79) and, following Contrada v. Italy (no. 3), held that the offence was not foreseeable before Demitry (§§ 70, 79).
The Court rejected arguments based on the Genco ruling (§§ 80–82), found it irrelevant that another offence might have applied (§ 83) and stressed that the Contrada finding is objective (§ 84). Domestic courts must establish when Demitry became accessible and whether all the conduct is affected (§§ 79, 93); reopening is available under Article 628-bis of the Code of Criminal Procedure (§ 92). Judges Sabato and Derenčinović dissented.
Why it matters for the defence
Lo Sicco rejects the reading of Contrada as limited to one person. Lawyers for anyone convicted of external complicity for conduct before late 1994 should check the dates of the charged conduct and consider an Article 628-bis request, noting that the judgment is not yet final. Elsewhere, it supports foreseeability challenges where liability rests on divided case law.
Kostov v. Hungary
Application no. 7869/25, Chamber judgment (Second Section) of 6 October 2026, not yet final. Article: 5 § 3 ECHR. Outcome: no violation (unanimous).
The facts
Norbert Kostov, a Slovak national, was arrested in Slovakia on 24 July 2020 under a European Arrest Warrant in a Hungarian double-murder investigation and surrendered to Hungary. The Buda Central District Court remanded him on grounds of flight risk, risk of tampering with evidence and risk of reoffending, and extended his detention several times until his conviction on 2 April 2025.
The Court's reasoning
In Kostov v. Hungary the European Court of Human Rights found no violation of Article 5 § 3 ECHR.
Why it matters for the defence
In a serious case where courts keep renewing their reasons, length alone rarely wins under Article 5 § 3. For clients surrendered under a European Arrest Warrant, the defence should test at every extension whether the original risks still rest on specific, current facts, and propose alternatives such as house arrest or electronic monitoring.
Watch list
On 15 October 2026 the Court accepted a request for an advisory opinion from the Supreme Court of the Netherlands on 2013 legislation that allows a final acquittal to be reviewed to the former defendant's detriment; the case concerns a 2012 murder acquittal challenged on the basis of new DNA techniques (Court announcement).
About the Joint Defense Team
The Joint Defense Team (JDT) is a European network of criminal defence lawyers, one per country, who work together on cross-border cases: encrypted-phone evidence (EncroChat, SkyECC, ANOM), extradition and the European Arrest Warrant, Interpol and Europol matters, and proceedings before the CJEU and the European Court of Human Rights. More at www.joint-defense-team.com.
Get the next edition by email
ECtHR Criminal Law Monthly appears once a month. Subscribe here to receive it by email.
This newsletter provides general information on the case law of the European Court of Human Rights. It is not legal advice and does not replace advice on an individual case.



